Instacart vs Doordash (Compared)

The food delivery market is booming, with more and more people opting for the convenience of online grocery shopping and food delivery services. Two major players in this industry are Instacart and Doordash. If you’re wondering which is better for your needs, join us as we delve into a detailed comparison of Instacart and Doordash, considering factors such as cost, user reviews, convenience, and speed of delivery.

Key Takeaways:

• Instacart and Doordash are leading players in the food delivery market, offering extensive market coverage.
• Instacart partners with major retailers like Kroger, Costco, and Target, while Doordash partners with over 340,000 restaurants and merchants.
• Both services have driver requirements, including age, work eligibility, and vehicle ownership.
• The pay structure differs between Instacart and Doordash but both services provide opportunities for additional earnings through tips and bonuses.
• Instacart pays its shoppers weekly via direct deposit, and Doordash also offers weekly payments with the option for instant cashout.
• Drivers for both services value the flexibility and autonomy the job offers, but some have reported a lack of support and appreciation.
• Both Instacart and Doordash prioritize driver safety and provide support services to ensure a safe working environment.

About Instacart and Doordash

When it comes to grocery and food delivery services, Instacart and Doordash are two popular names that often come up. Let’s take a closer look at what sets them apart.

Instacart

Established in 2012, Instacart is an on-demand grocery delivery service that has quickly gained popularity. It operates in over 5,500 cities across the United States and Canada, making it a convenient option for many customers. Instacart has partnered with major retailers like Kroger, Costco, and Target, ensuring a wide range of grocery options for users.

Doordash

On the other hand, Doordash is an on-demand food delivery service that was founded in 2013. It covers over 4,000 cities, making it a popular choice for those looking to have restaurant meals delivered to their doorstep. Doordash has established partnerships with over 340,000 restaurants and merchants, offering a diverse selection of cuisines.

Both Instacart and Doordash have gained popularity due to their extensive market coverage and the convenience they offer to customers. Whether you’re looking for groceries or restaurant meals, these platforms have you covered.

Driver Requirements

When considering driving for Instacart or Doordash, it’s important to understand the driver requirements for each platform. Here are the details you need to know:

Instacart

To become a driver for Instacart, you must meet the following requirements:

• Age Requirement: You must be at least 18 years old to qualify.
• Work Eligibility: You need to be eligible to work in the United States.
• Vehicle Requirement: Full-service shoppers are required to have consistent access to a vehicle for grocery deliveries. In-store shoppers need reliable transportation to get to and from work.
• Smartphone Requirement: You need a smartphone to effectively use the Instacart app for order management and communication with customers.
• Background Check: Instacart requires all drivers to consent to a background check to ensure safety and security.

Doordash

For Doordash, the driver requirements are similar:

• Age Requirement: You must be at least 18 years old to be eligible.
• Work Eligibility: You need to meet the work eligibility requirements in the United States.
• Vehicle Requirement: If you choose to drive, you need a valid driver’s license and access to a vehicle for deliveries. However, if you opt for biking or walking deliveries, no vehicle is required.
• Smartphone Requirement: Similar to Instacart, you need a smartphone to use the Doordash app for accepting and managing delivery orders.
• Background Check: Doordash also requires drivers to pass a background check to ensure safety for all parties involved.

Both Instacart and Doordash prioritize safety and require background checks for their drivers. Additionally, having a smartphone is essential for using the respective apps for order management. Depending on the type of deliveries you prefer, access to a reliable vehicle may be necessary.

Overall, make sure you meet the specific driver requirements that Instacart and Doordash have in place to ensure eligibility and a smooth onboarding process.

Pay Comparison

When comparing the pay structures of Instacart and Doordash, there are several factors to consider that can affect the earnings potential of drivers. Let’s take a closer look at how both platforms compensate their drivers.

Instacart Pay

Instacart’s pay structure varies depending on the type of shopper you are, the number of orders you complete, and your location. Full-service shoppers, who handle both shopping and delivery, receive an estimate of the expected payout before each delivery. The pay for full-service shoppers is based on factors such as the number of items, driving distance, and effort involved in the delivery. On the other hand, in-store shoppers, who focus solely on shopping, receive a flat hourly wage.

Doordash Pay

Doordash pays its drivers per delivery, with base pay ranging from $2 to $10. Factors such as distance, order complexity, and other variables can affect the base pay rate. Dashers also have the opportunity to earn more through promotions like Peak Pay and Challenges, where they can receive additional incentives and bonuses.

Both Instacart and Doordash allow drivers to keep 100% of their tips. This means that the tips customers give to drivers are not shared with the platform and directly impact the earnings of drivers.

It is worth noting that the actual pay you earn from Instacart or Doordash can vary depending on factors such as demand, order volume, and the geographical area in which you operate. It’s important to consider these variables when estimating your potential earnings on either platform.

Note: The pay information provided above is based on general observations and should be considered as a general guideline. Pay rates may vary depending on the region, time, and other factors.

Payment Process

One of the critical factors to consider when comparing Instacart and Doordash is the payment process. Both services offer convenient and timely payments to their drivers.

Instacart Payment

Instacart pays its shoppers on a weekly basis through direct deposit. This means that once a week, the earnings are automatically transferred to the shopper’s bank account. In-store shoppers also have the option to request a physical check for their payments.

Full-service shoppers on Instacart can also take advantage of the Instant Cashout feature. This feature allows them to transfer their earnings instantly to their debit card. This not only provides flexibility but also ensures that shoppers have quick access to their funds.

Doordash Payment

Similar to Instacart, Doordash pays its drivers weekly via direct deposit. Most drivers receive their payments by Wednesday, providing a consistent and reliable source of income. Doordash also offers a feature called Fast Pay, which allows drivers to cash out their earnings on the same day they make deliveries.

While Fast Pay offers instant access to earnings, it’s important to note that there is a small transaction fee associated with each use. However, this added convenience may be worth it for drivers who prefer immediate access to their funds.

To summarize:

Overall, both Instacart and Doordash provide efficient payment processes that cater to the needs of their drivers. Whether you prefer the flexibility of instant cashout or the reliability of weekly deposits, both services ensure that drivers are compensated for their work on a regular basis.

Job Review

Working as a shopper for Instacart or a dasher for Doordash offers unique opportunities and experiences. Let’s take a closer look at what it’s like to work for these popular food delivery services.

Flexibility and Autonomy

One of the major perks of both Instacart and Doordash is the flexibility they offer. As an Instacart shopper, you have the freedom to choose your own hours and decide when you want to work. This level of flexibility allows you to create a schedule that fits your lifestyle and other commitments.

Similarly, Doordash dashers enjoy the autonomy of being their own boss. You have the power to accept or decline delivery requests based on your availability. This autonomy gives you control over how many hours you work and the potential to earn additional income.

Purpose and Support

Instacart shoppers find satisfaction in their work by helping customers with their grocery needs. By ensuring that customers receive fresh and high-quality products, shoppers play a crucial role in making people’s lives easier and more convenient.

While Instacart shoppers appreciate the purpose they derive from their work, some have expressed a desire for more support from the company. It is important to continue improving the support systems and create a supportive and inclusive work environment for shoppers.

Doordash dashers also value the purpose they find in their work, delivering meals to people’s doors and satisfying their hunger. However, some dashers have reported feeling a lack of support and appreciation from management. It is crucial for Doordash to address these concerns and provide adequate support to their drivers.

Work Environment

The work environments for both Instacart and Doordash are dynamic and ever-changing. As a shopper or a dasher, you are constantly on the move, interacting with customers and delivering orders. This active work environment allows you to be out and about, which can be enjoyable for those who prefer to avoid a desk job.

However, it is important to note that the work environment may vary depending on your location and the specific tasks assigned to you. It’s essential to adapt to different situations and be prepared to handle various challenges that may arise during the course of your work.

In conclusion, both Instacart and Doordash offer opportunities for flexible work, autonomy, and a sense of purpose. However, it is crucial for both companies to address the support and work environment concerns raised by their shoppers and dashers. By investing in better support systems and creating a positive work environment, both Instacart and Doordash can continue to attract and retain talented drivers who are dedicated to providing exceptional service.

Driver Support Comparison

When it comes to driver support and safety features, both Instacart and DoorDash prioritize the well-being of their drivers. They offer various services and tools to ensure a safe working environment and address any concerns that may arise.

Instacart Driver Support

Instacart provides in-app safety alerts to notify drivers of any unsafe conditions they may encounter while delivering orders. These alerts help drivers stay informed and take necessary precautions to ensure their safety on the road. In addition, Instacart has a dedicated support team that is available to address any safety concerns or issues that drivers may have. This ensures that drivers can feel confident and supported while working for Instacart.

DoorDash Driver Support

DoorDash takes driver support and safety seriously by offering occupational accident insurance to cover injuries sustained while delivering. This insurance provides an additional layer of protection and peace of mind for drivers in the event of an accident or injury on the job. DoorDash also provides SafeDash, a safety toolkit that offers fast and easy access to assistance and support. This toolkit includes features such as an emergency assistance button and 24/7 live support, ensuring that drivers can receive help whenever they need it.

Both Instacart and DoorDash understand the importance of driver support and safety. They have implemented measures and tools to ensure that their drivers can work in a secure environment and have access to the support they need. This commitment to driver well-being sets both companies apart and demonstrates their dedication to providing a positive driver experience.

Image:

Conclusion

After carefully considering factors such as pay, job requirements, support, and safety features, it is clear that both Instacart and Doordash have their merits for drivers. Instacart offers higher earnings potential, especially for full-service shoppers, but Doordash provides more variety and flexibility in terms of delivery options.

Driver preferences and priorities play a crucial role in choosing the best platform. If drivers value higher earning potential and are comfortable with grocery delivery, Instacart is a great choice. On the other hand, drivers who prioritize variety and flexibility in terms of delivery options may find Doordash to be more suitable.

It is important for drivers to carefully evaluate their options and consider their own preferences before making a decision. Both services have their strengths and weaknesses, and what works best for one driver may not work for another. By thoroughly assessing factors like earnings potential, job requirements, support, and safety, drivers can make an informed choice that aligns with their needs and goals.